Jump to content

Xystophoroi

Member
  • Content count

    345
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    5

Xystophoroi last won the day on March 26

Xystophoroi had the most liked content!

About Xystophoroi

  • Rank
    Altcap

Recent Profile Visitors

595 profile views
  1. Xystophoroi

    May 4th Q&A discussion

    For those of us not in the know, what does the consolidation in DW look like? Removing factions? As in, no more Ryushi ever. Or just merging them together so instead of being able to play an Omnidyne fleet you instead take a 'Directorate' fleet and take 90% of the ships as Omnidyne models?
  2. I'm going to Salute this year in London on the 14th. I note that Wayland have a stall, any chance there will be anything Firestorm to pick up or being talked about there?
  3. Xystophoroi

    The Sorylians shall rise again!

    I am all for getting characterful new buffs for the Sorylians but I want to step in and say that reliance on Shunt Entry is, I think hugely overstated. As in. I do worse when I use Shunt Entry as Sorylians. Deploying on the table and driving across it has yielded better results for me, consistently. The big thing is accepting you are doing nothing of note for the first two turns and instead hiding behind any terrain feature that'll have you. You're fast, your guns have 16" optimal range on commonly 10" movement hulls. In a single turn you can reach out and hit something ~26" away with optimal firepower (more realistically something 22" once you accommodate for turns, arc optimising, etc.). You need to huddle for PD cover form interceptors. It's lame but it's needed. The problem is predictability. Typically a non-shunt game looks like this 0. Deploy behind 1/2AD cover 1. Move forward, staying behind 1/2AD cover, take a few random HP from torps getting through PD or lucky shots going through 1/2AD 2. Repeat previous turn, if something would be in range if you just darted out to attack it and left your cover...don't dart out, it's more important to arrive as a coordinated force than to dash around chasing hits. Hopefully you've minimised incoming damage, maybe a random torpedo has done something to one of their ships, not really important. 3. Your fleet comes out all at once, drives to max, etc. you get as many ships into arc and mixed into their fleet as possible and just open up. Your range and speed means that most of your ships should be perfectly capable of opening up on them in at least two arcs. Looking to secure kills. Basically you're trying to make it so the game doesn't get to happen in any meaningful way until turn 3. The issue I found with Shunt Entry reliance was that things arrived in dribs and drabs and would get focus fired. It depended on winning initiative to get use out of it's shunted ships. It relied on additional resources like TAC to arrive when you needed them to. The 50% you'd put on the table just gets beaten up because they can focus fire more. At time constrained things like tournaments I'd find missions had gone past the critical point before things had enough time to Shunt in. Considering your speed and weapon range you're better Flanking than Shunting but even then I'd only do it with something that I won't mind missing out on for a little while. Now, is this competitive? Not really. Best I did with Sorylians is 3rd at Reading but I did find that abandoning the Shunt Focus helped me win more and enjoy playing them more. it's just lame that the faction that attracted me to them because they were 'super tough' have to hide for half the game (either off table flank/shunt or crawling behind rocks) to have a chance of surviving long enough to have a chance of winning.
  4. Xystophoroi

    Line of Sight, and Screening Ships

    How do WW2 aircraft and fighter escorts protect warships from incoming enemy aircraft? Or convoy escorts protect merchant ships against submarine wolf packs? Could either or both be implemented here? Pretty sure neither were big on physically blocking incoming shots with their hulls so much as creating danger zones the attacker could not move into without the threat of retaliation taking them down. I.e.: picture less 'I am the shield and you have to get through me to get to my charge!' and more 'incoming enemy fighters detected, 50 miles out, on intercept course with our fleet, contact in 20 minutes, scramble fighters, take them down before they reach us!'
  5. Xystophoroi

    Casualties in Space Combat

    Mission kill vs actual kill. I dig it.
  6. Xystophoroi

    Future FA rules

    Yes, I am a fan of the battlelog and the incentives it provides to withdraw to save lives and extremely valuable war materiel. An example of rules feeding into theme and setting. It's an intragalactic war fought using massive ships with many lives and huge resource investments. You can't just waste lives and ships in pursuit of victory in this one engagement if it deprives you of an effective fleet in being, etc.
  7. Xystophoroi

    Future FA rules

    I believe that's already a rule - if your Battlelog ever gets to the maximum negative you immediately FSD the entire fleet and lose. Happened to me at reading Warfare once. AGainst some gorgeous purple and bone/white Veydreth. My Sorylians vs Veydreth, Veydreth gunships floated forward and crit my Battleship turn 1 with their beams, they did the same on turn 2 leaving it on 4HP half way up the table and in range of every beam in the Veydreth fleet with the rest of their fleet still to activate.
  8. Xystophoroi

    Future FA rules

    Yes, basically because of things like the game state required to get a Battleship down at 4hp and likely use cases of a battleship (actually getting into weapon range to fight) if you wait too long (with too long being ~4hp in my experience) the time spent charging up the FSD just gets it killed and it;s usually worth it for the big battle log swing taking out a battleship is worth. You often don't even have to overexpose yourself to get those last hits on the ship either as many ships have weapons in multiple arcs so they still contribute to fighting the rest of the enemy fleet while putting a weapon system on the battleship.
  9. Xystophoroi

    Future FA rules

    It dies. Consider the table situation that has left a battleship on 2hp. How did it drop that low? Enemies must be in range to hit it with enough firepower to at least overcome DR and shields right? It is unlikely you can degrade enemy squadrons fast enough to prevent them putting those remaining HP on the battleship before it is able to sit still for 2 turns (or 1 full turn if you activate the battleship as your last activation) and charge up the FSD. Hell a single crit would take it out and most battleships are in the 11CR range...a linked squadron can get there fairly reliably and taking out a battleship is a lot of battle log so it's often worth it to sacrifice ships for that kill. In my games i have found that if you're using the battleship to actually fight then once it hits 4hp it's not going to be able to escape - unless it was some lucky early criticals while it is still deep on your half of the table.
  10. Xystophoroi

    Future FA rules

    Who said they're leaving without orders? Edit: Also, entire reams of military theory are about breaking morale so I'd go with the suspicion that most commanders know troops on both sides will run away regardless of their orders to the contrary.
  11. Xystophoroi

    Future FA rules

    Would like to see more Fold Space escaping really, making it less of a mostly stupid option would be a plus. I think that currently Battleships really need to be starting their jump preparations when they're down to 6hp remaining if they actually want to escape. If you wait to be a half HP (about 4) then your ship is in a situation where it has been under enough firepower to be vulnerable which means it's probably in fighting range and the ships that took it to 4hp are probably just waiting for their chance to do another bit of damage. Several turns of sitting exposed is not a good idea and those kinds of ships usually don't have the speed and maneuverability to hide on a part of the table that will keep them safe for 2 turns of inactivity. And yes, I know, we're not wet navy operations but the Bismarck (and Prince Eugen) fought with the Hood and Wales, Hood was destroyed and Wales escaped to tail the German ships. Bismarck took 3 hits and was badly damaged enough to need to cancel their mission and try to escape to return to base for repairs. The closest thing we have for our ships in the real world try to - and succeed - in escaping (Wales got away from the battle of the Denmark Strait) and ships taking damage return to base (mission kills rather than actual kills). For me it feels more thematic for ships to try and escape as much as possible rather than fighting and dying. It makes it feel like there are real people on board and that there are bigger strategic concerns in a massive intragalactic war than this single engagement.
  12. Xystophoroi

    Squadron Activation

    Wrath of Kings has a different activation system, related to the 'Alternating Activations' style. You have a number of models, they can activate as individuals. You also have 'command' figures who can activate multiple models as a single activation. Both players trade activating a model/group if a 'commander' orders it like 'Alternating Activations'. Once one player has run out of activations their opponent gets to make ONE more activation, then the turn ends. You are rewarded for being as efficient with your models and 'commanders' as possible and it removes the 'activation advantage' issue that can occur in some 'Alternating Activation' games. It's probably not offering much to FSA as spamming tiny squadrons for activation advantage is not currently a good idea for other reasons so most fleets are usually within +/-1 squadron of each other. ==== Another activation system I have seen is one where the player rolls a handful of dice (about 4 I think) and can spend the results to do things. Lower results let them move smaller/weaker stuff and you can spend higher results to be lower results. E.g.: 1 = move a T3 squadron 2 = move a T2 squadron 3 = Move a non-Dreadnought T1 Squadron 4 = Move a Dreadnought Squadron 5 = Something special 6 = End the turn Once you have rolled and spent your dice your opponent rolls and spends theirs. You could repeatedly activate the same squadron if you wanted to (with probably some degrading effect if you do so too many times). The 5 does something special which could be worked out later. The 6 ends the turn. Only by one player spending a 6 do any of the 'end of turn' effects like repairs, returning SRS to base, etc. occur. The idea is to simulate a kind of ebb and flow of periods of intense activity followed by a lull period. ==== not saying any are necessarily good for FSA, just that there are more 'turn systems' out there to maybe steal ideas from.
  13. Xystophoroi

    Future FA rules

    @Frans How do you forsee combat in space as being different from 'Naval' space combat games? How does a ships/squadron's movement differ between the two systems? I really like the thematic stuff like being able to go belly up, or perhaps front over back to face directly behind you (then continue moving in the original direction of movement at half speed as you decelerate that way and then go back where you came from). Maybe boarding has to be done with short range teleporters rather than trying to explain away the speed boarding craft would slam into the enemy hull. Bombers dropping stuff is probably not a thing and instead 'bombers' are firing high payload torpedoes at short ranges.
  14. Xystophoroi

    Less Dice Rolls, More Game

    I suggest 1. the big criticals that cause 'one hit KO' potential should be rarer or only be possible once a ship has already sustained meaningful damage so that a turn one lucky crit does not cripple a battleship. E.g.: something like if you roll a double 1 the target ship takes either +1 damage and choose a status effect if over half HP or if under half HP +2 damage and choose two status effects 2. You only roll to repair status effect at the END of the squadron's activation (or some other time tied to the ships in questions) so that you have a longer period of time to both suffer under the effects and a longer period of time in which to exploit the effects of enemy status effects. Rolling to shut down the enemy shields as the last activation of your turn and then having them just repair immediately renders the whole endeavour of rolling for a crit irrelevant. If you go for 2 allow the Experienced Engineers MAR to roll to repair at the start of the squadron activation or if TACs are still around use the Focused Repair TAC at the start of the turn to guarantee Crit Removal, etc.
  15. Xystophoroi

    Is the 3.0 in the pipeline scrapped

    I hope they just entirely get rid of the proximity vectoring stuff. Let people remove models from their flight stems when things get in close. Just treat the base footprint and flight stem as what matters mechanically. Let people change their flight stem height to suit their preference. If you need to then make the base size an actual model stat to keep it consistent (like Wrath of Kings does).
×

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.